Orthodontic SEO Case Study: Almost Six Years With Mack Orthodontics

Last updated: November 19, 2026

Key Takeaways

  • Mack Orthodontics had never done digital marketing before partnering with Neon Canvas. After almost six years, its case study projects +418% growth in local search rankings. That figure is a projection, not a measured result.
  • Paid ads ran alongside SEO, “netting an average of 39 leads per month at a cost of just $23.80 per lead”. That is a cost per lead, not a cost per start.
  • The page’s 177x yearly ROI and 9,447 new patient leads are projections, based on Mack’s average patient value and conversion rate. Read them that way.
  • The lesson for other practices: SEO, ads, a real website and authentic photography worked together, and the visibility gains came from years of consistent work.

This orthodontic SEO case study follows Mack Orthodontics, a practice that went from no digital presence to a full search and paid ads program over almost six years with Neon Canvas. Below is what was built, what the numbers do and don’t mean, and what other practices can take from it.

We are going to be careful with the numbers. Case studies in our industry often blur measured results and projections. We would rather show you exactly which is which, so you can judge the work honestly.

Where did Mack Orthodontics start?

Mack Orthodontics started with no digital marketing at all. According to the Mack Orthodontics case study, the practice “had never ventured into digital marketing before partnering with Neon Canvas.”

The goal had two parts. Reach a bigger audience, and do it without losing the welcoming, down-to-earth feel that kept existing patients coming back. That second part matters. Plenty of practices get more visible and less recognizable at the same time.

What did Neon Canvas build for Mack?

Four pieces, working together: SEO, paid advertising, a new website and a custom photo and video library. None of them would have carried the result alone.

PieceWhat it did
SEOGrew local visibility across the search terms that matter to the practice
Paid adsProduced a steady flow of leads while organic visibility grew
WebsiteFull-width office photos, a soft brand blue and a friendly serif font for a warm, modern feel
Photo and videoA library of candid images of real patients, real smiles and the real office experience

The SEO work sits at the center. The basics of local visibility are public: Google says local results are “mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity” in its Google Business Profile Help article on local ranking. A practice can’t change its distance from a searcher, so the work goes into relevance (clear, complete information and pages about the treatments you offer) and prominence (reviews, links and reputation). Our orthodontic SEO approach follows that same logic.

The website was built to support it. The case study describes large, full-width photos as the focal point “so we could let their authentic office images shine.” Our orthodontic website design work starts from the practice’s personality for exactly this reason. And the imagery came from a custom shoot, not stock, through our practice photography and video team.

What results did Mack Orthodontics see?

The case study page describes two results in its body text and shows two headline figures it calls projections. Here is each one, worded the way the page words it.

MetricWhat the page saysType
Local search visibility“+418%” local search rankingsProjection
Paid ad leads“an average of 39 leads per month at a cost of just $23.80 per lead”Reported result (cost per lead)
Yearly ROI177xProjection
New patient leads9,447Projection

The footnote under the page’s headline figures reads: “These numbers are projections based on Mack Orthodontics’ average patient valuation and conversion rate.” They are estimates built from the practice’s own figures, not counted patients or booked revenue. They are useful as a sense of scale. They are not a promise of what any other practice will see.

Is the +418% local search figure a measured result?

No. The case study shows “+418%” local search rankings in the same stat block as the ROI and lead figures, and the footnote under that block says the numbers “are projections based on Mack Orthodontics’ average patient valuation and conversion rate.” We read it as a projection of how much more visible Mack became in local search, not a counted result.

It is also a visibility figure. Even as a projection, it is not the same as a 418% increase in patients or revenue, and we would never claim it is. Visibility is the top of the funnel. It earns the chance at a call, and the practice still has to answer, book and convert.

It also came from a practice that started at zero. Growth percentages are always larger from a small base, which is one more reason to read them in context.

How did paid ads fit alongside SEO?

Paid ads gave Mack a dependable stream of leads while organic visibility was still growing. The case study says the paid approach “further solidified their digital footprint, netting an average of 39 leads per month at a cost of just $23.80 per lead”.

Two notes on reading that number. First, it is a cost per lead. It measures what an inquiry cost, not what a started patient cost, which depends on how many leads book and accept treatment. Second, the page does not state the time span behind the average, so we won’t guess at one.

Connecting leads to outcomes is what turns a number like that into a decision. Google describes how conversions let you “choose what you identify as valuable, like a purchase, sign-up, or phone call” in Google Ads Help on conversion measurement. For an orthodontic practice, the conversions worth defining are calls, consult requests and, ideally, starts. Our search engine marketing team builds campaigns around those.

Why did the results take almost six years?

Because the biggest gains in local search compound. Google’s SEO Starter Guide notes that “Some changes might take effect in a few hours, others could take several months.” Reviews, links, content and reputation build on each other, and each year of steady work makes the next year’s gains easier to hold.

The case study frames the result as the outcome of just under six years of partnership. It does not break out results by year, so we can’t tell you what happened in month six versus year five. What we can say is that this was not a 90-day sprint, and no honest SEO case study should pretend to be one.

Google’s own advice to anyone hiring an SEO is to ask “What kind of results do you expect to see, and in what timeframe?” and to remember that “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google,” per Do you need an SEO? Mack’s story is a good illustration of why that question matters.

What can other orthodontic practices learn from Mack?

That visibility, trust and conversion have to be built together, and kept going. Here is the checklist we would hand any practice starting where Mack started.

  1. Start with your practice’s personality. Mack wanted to stay down-to-earth. The brand, site and photos all protected that.
  2. Use real photos. Authentic office and patient imagery builds trust that stock can’t.
  3. Run SEO and ads together. Ads produce leads now. SEO builds visibility that keeps working.
  4. Measure leads, then starts. A low cost per lead is a good sign, not the finish line.
  5. Label projections honestly. In your own reports and in any agency’s case study, ask which numbers were counted and which were estimated.
  6. Commit to the long game. Plan in years, review quarterly, and judge progress by trend.

For more on how local visibility is earned, see our guide to winning the Google Maps results parents see, and for the review side, how orthodontic reviews drive patient volume. For the bigger picture, our deep dive on SEO as a long-term patient engine covers where search is heading.

Frequently Asked Questions

What results did Mack Orthodontics get from SEO?

The Mack Orthodontics case study on neoncanvas.com reports paid ads netting an average of 39 leads per month at $23.80 per lead, after almost six years with Neon Canvas. The practice had no digital marketing before the partnership. The same page’s +418% local search rankings, 177x yearly ROI and 9,447 new patient leads are labeled as projections based on the practice’s average patient value and conversion rate.

Is the 177x ROI in the Mack case study a measured result?

No. The case study’s footnote says the yearly ROI and the projected new patient leads are projections based on Mack Orthodontics’ average patient valuation and conversion rate. They are estimates built from the practice’s own figures, not counted results. They show scale, but they are not a promise of what another practice will achieve.

How long does an orthodontic SEO case study need to run to be meaningful?

Long enough to show a trend, not a spike. Google says some SEO changes take hours and others take several months, so a few weeks of data says little. Look for case studies that state their time frame, separate measured results from projections, and connect visibility to leads. The Mack case study covers almost six years.

Is $23.80 per lead the same as cost per new patient?

No. The Mack case study reports an average of 39 paid ad leads per month at $23.80 per lead. That measures the cost of an inquiry, such as a call or form. Cost per new patient start also depends on how many of those leads book a consult and accept treatment, which the case study does not report.

Want to See What Your Practice’s Numbers Could Look Like?

Every practice starts somewhere different. Request a free orthodontic marketing audit and we will show you where your visibility, tracking and lead flow stand today.

Join our Newsletter